Which does ATC not require you to read back?

Sep 28, 2026

Which does ATC not require you to read back? (Per the AIM and FAA JO 7110.65.)

ATurn right heading 180

Readback of vectors is one of the three items the AIM specifically calls out: altitude assignments, vectors, and runway assignments. A heading is a vector, so you should always read it back. The answer is C, the altimeter setting.

Read the full explanation
BHold short runway 27

The AIM tells pilots to read back any hold short instruction (4-3-18), and the controllers' rulebook, JO 7110.65 (3-7-2), tells them to ask for the readback if you don't give one. The answer is C, the altimeter setting.

Read the full explanation
CLocal altimeter is 3010

You got it. The AIM's readback list (4-4-7) covers altitude assignments, vectors, and runway assignments. An altimeter setting isn't on it, so a simple acknowledgment meets the expectation. Reading it back is still a good habit, and plenty of CFIs teach it, but ATC doesn't require it.

Read the full explanation
DDescend at pilot's discretion, maintain 3000

"Pilot's discretion" makes this one sound optional, right? The discretion only applies to when you start down and how fast you descend (AIM 4-4-10). The 3000 is still an altitude assignment, and altitude assignments get read back. The answer is C, the altimeter setting.

Read the full explanation

Pick an answer. You can try as many as you like.

Read the full explanation
The explanation

C. Local altimeter is 3010

The AIM's readback list

AIM 4-4-7 asks pilots to read back the parts of ATC clearances and instructions that contain altitude assignments, vectors or runway assignments, as a means of mutual verification. A heading is a vector, so "turn right heading 180" gets read back. An altimeter setting isn't on the list, so a simple acknowledgment meets the expectation.

Hold short instructions

Hold short instructions get read back too. AIM 4-3-18 tells pilots to read back any hold short instruction, and the controllers' rulebook, FAA JO 7110.65 (3-7-2), tells them to ask for the readback if you don't give one.

Pilot's discretion

"Descend at pilot's discretion, maintain 3000" sounds optional, but the discretion only covers when you start down and how fast you descend (AIM 4-4-10). The 3000 is still an altitude assignment, and altitude assignments get read back.

Read it back anyway

Reading back the altimeter setting is still a good habit, and plenty of CFIs teach it. Outside the U.S., ICAO rules and countries like the UK do require it, which is why this quiz is specifically about the AIM and JO 7110.65.

References

Share your thoughts / Suggest a quiz

Tell us what you thought of this quiz, or suggest a topic for a future one.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Train With Your CFI

Fly the syllabus at your own pace. Practice in VR and impress your flight instructor with how fast you improve.

Learn to fly solo